When 10-year-old Zach Ramsay vanished on his way to school the investigation into what happened led police down a deeply disturbing path as they tried to find who was responsible.

In July 2022 a woman found buckets full of human remains in her basement. The investigation into where these remains came from would quickly lead police to one of the most prestigious universities in the United States.

When 21-year-old Dawn Rossignol disappeared early one morning on her way to a doctor’s appointment authorities quickly learned that her killer should have been stopped decades before.

Thank you to Delly Mozingo for researching and writing this story!

21-year-old Tori Bethel was found dead in her apartment in 2022 and police failed to investigate her death as a homicide despite overwhelming evidence that it was. This week we had the honor of speaking with her family about the case to get the full picture of just how badly the system failed them and left potential suspects free to hurt more people.

In this episode we finish up the story of serial killer, Gary Hilton, by talking about his first 3 known victims.

When 24-year-old Meredith Emerson went for a hike on January 1st, 2008 she wanted to start off the new year doing something she loved. Unfortunately she wouldn’t have the chance to see what the new year would bring.

In 2006, a 32 year old man entered an Amish one-room schoolhouse and committed an unthinkable act.

In 2000, 16 year old Leesa Marie Gray was looking forward to finishing high school and going to college to become a teacher but she crossed paths with a man who would destroy everything.

When 58-year-old Todd Stout is found murdered in his temporary home under a bridge his killer would turn out to be one of the last people anyone would expect.

The Rhoden family went to bed on April 21st, 2016 and when they woke up the next day, their world had been blown apart.